Janice Cox’s Shropshire’s non-Conformist chapels website here tells us that the chapel at Overley Hill belonging to the United Methodist Free Church was built in 1858 . The chapel was still in existence in 1906 but had closed by 1935 when it was de-registered as a place of worship. The chapel was demolished sometime after 1945.
The only oddity is that the Ordnance Survey maps of 1882 and 1902 label the chapel as Wesleyan rather than United Methodist Free Church . Janice believes this is simply an error by the Survey. “There definitely wasn’t another chapel in Overley Hill. I have rechecked all the sources & it definitely was UMFC.”
Location: Grid Ref SJ 60801 10819